3
APR

Smoking Ban Increases Accidents 12 Percent

Share this article: Share this article del.icio.us Share this article digg Share this article google Share this article netscape Share this article reddit Share this article myweb Share this article fark Share this article furl
Ban on smoking causes crashes - study

A ban on smoking in American bars has increased the number of accidents apparently caused by drinking and driving.

US jurisdictions with a smoking ban have seen, on average, a nearly 12 percent rise in the number of drink-related accidents at the wheel, researchers say in a paper published in the Journal of Public Economics.

It's based on data from 2000 to 2005, drawn from counties that enforced a ban on smoking in bars during this period and from accident statistics before and after the ban was introduced.

Researchers found that instead of heading to their local bar for a drink and a puff, smokers ventured farther afield in search of a place where lighting up is still allowed

They may not be drinking more than before but they are certainly driving more - and that's what is increasing the risk of a crash.

The study said: "Banning smoking in bars increases the fatal accident risk posed by drunk drivers.

"Our evidence is consistent with two mechanisms -- smokers searching for alternative locations to drink within a locality and smokers driving to nearby jurisdictions that allow smoking in bars."

According figures cited in the report, nearly a one-third of the US population lives in cities, counties or states where there are restrictions on smoking in bars.

Study authors Scott Adams and Chad Cotti of the University of Wisconsin say the increase in drunk driving has to be weighed against "potential positive health impacts" from smoking bans, and this may take years to determine. - Sapa-AFP

Source

Apr 03, 2008 1:32 am   Email to a Friend

Comments

thatguy on Apr 09, 2009 3:47 am

WOW your advocating repealing a law because people are breaking a law... now theres some sound political thinking there. Not only that but doesn't it make you worry that smoking maybe so addictive that people are risking their lives just to have a puff?

dewi on Apr 01, 2009 10:51 pm

Do not sell any cigrets

donkey on Feb 16, 2009 5:31 pm

So what we're saying here is that nicotine is so addictive people consciously make a choice to put themselves and others at increased danger in order to enjoy their God given right to enjoy a smoke in a bar.

This is just garbage. It says a lot of things about smoking and smokers...but I don't think it's any of the things you think or want it to say.

NoSmoker on Dec 09, 2008 7:52 am

I find positive side in ban smoking everywhere. New generation will be more vulnerable even without smoking problems.

PJD on Oct 01, 2008 12:47 pm

Smoking Bans do not cause increases in drinking and driving, drinking and driving causes drinking and driving. The fact you post this article is ridiculous. Similar to people kill people, guns do not kill people. If people stopped drinking and driving there would be zero drinking and driving deaths. Which would not be affected by smoking bans in any way. I would look for better facts and reasoning for your cause.

mehek on Sep 09, 2008 12:43 am

But many people DO travel that far away for a night out (so they can drink & smoke). Most choose places closer to the border, but I can see where people might sometimes, make the longer trip (longer trip home after drinking equals more drunk drivers on the road). My daughter & her friends (within 15 minutes from a bar in Michigan) would go to bars on weekends that were very close to home so they could take a taxi home without breaking the bank.
---------------
Mehek

Shining on Aug 12, 2008 7:56 am

They seem to 'forget' the fact that one of the (mostly positive) effects of smoking tabacco is an increase in concentration.

Write a comment

* = required field

:

:

:


7 + 2 =